City of Joy, 1992, Roland Joffé
True heroism lies in the quality of the struggle. Directed by Roland Joffé, City of Joy is an emotional roller-coaster of two men from different parts of the world, and shows how they fit into the bigger picture of the working life in India. Initially comprising of slow motion medium close-up shots, and lots of jump cuts between Max, his nurses, his patient and the hospital, the viewer is introduced to a focused and concentration-driven environment: Max’s operating room. The slow motion effect makes every movement of the doctors and nurses slow and precise. The only sound the viewer hears is the patient’s heart rate monitor, which gradually slows down and gets louder as his heart ceases. The combined effects of the sound and camera shots creates a sense of urgency and panic, which is subsides when Max bursts out of the O.R. in defeat and morphs into feelings of bemusement. At this time, the viewer hears the voiceover of a conversation between Max and his father discussing Max’s failures, revealing his father’s disapproval. Due to these events and those prior to it, Max leaves on a plane for India.
India is a crowded place – and that’s an understatement! To show the large crowds, several types of shots are used, primarily the full shot because they capture a wide area. Moving shots are also used effectively to demonstrate the concentration of people in a typical Indian street or train station. For example, when Hazari and his family are moving through a street to ask shopkeepers for work, the viewer never has a direct view of them – there’s always something in the way, such as a car or a person or a horse. These shots demonstrate the intricacy of India and how it differs from the USA.
Moving shots are also frequently used to demonstrate the complexity of each scene – there is so much going on at once and Max, or Hazari and his family just happen to be part of the grander scheme of things. For example, half way through the movie, when Max is helping rebuild a house, the viewer sees him briefly but then proceeds to see how other unnamed or minor characters are also collaborating, until getting back to Max through the moving shot.
Joffé uses a lot of low-angle shots to look up at the characters, though not always with the intention of giving one character more power over the other. For example, when Hazari is looking for a job as a “human horse” to pull a rickshaw, the camera angle is lower than all the characters and looks up at them. This is interesting because it makes it seem like they are all important – the unchanging camera angle doesn’t put the employer at a higher position than the employee.
Over-the-shoulder shots are used occasionally to give a dynamic look to dialogue between characters. A more intimate relationship – such as a friend or family member – is suggested when medium close-up shots are used rather than medium or long shots.
During the majority of the film, in scenes with a lot of depth, the foreground is usually in focus and the background is blurred. This draws focus to the characters having a conversation, while providing an animated, colorful and interactive backdrop – it’s so busy, and yet people are in a world of their own as they carry out their daily lives.
Chaos is shown through fast cuts in shots of aggression and violence. For example, when Max and Hazari are trying to fight back an angry mob and protect the victim leper population, the viewer sees several shots of their defense efforts, as well as rallying the lepers into a sort of safehouse, followed by the attack of the mob, and everything in between. The rapid cuts give the impression that all these occurrences are happening at once, thus leading the viewer to a sense of chaos and disorder. Moreover, the victims of the attacks – such as the man with no legs who has a fire bomb thrown at him – are shown at eye-level long shots, while Ashok, the man who orchestrated the mob to show Joan why the leper center needs his protection, is seen from a low-angle camera shot, giving him more power over the chaos they are overlooking. Finally, Joan admits that she needs his protection from such attacks and decides to pay him, so because of his threat, he did in fact have the upper hand in the scene.
The reaction shots of this movie are very interestingly executed. The majority are medium shots and tend to pull away from the character’s face, but one that stands out as being a very personal reaction shot is when Max sees Amrita after her attack that resulted in her mouth being cut at the ends, similar to the Joker from Batman. His reaction shot is only momentary but reveals the horror in his eyes effectively. Another interesting reaction shot is when Ashok takes Hazari’s rickshaw away. It begins as a two-shot, and then graduates quickly to medium close-up shots of each character as they talk to one another. The viewer sees Hazari from a high angle shot, making him inferior, and Ashok from a low angle shot, giving him more power in the scene. However, when Hazari hears that Ashok is taking away his rickshaw, he immediately reacts and this draws the camera to him in a moving shot, which captures not only Hazari’s reaction but also the two men who are sent to confiscate his rickshaw.
On a lighter note, one of the most heartwarming reaction shots in this movie occurs when Hazari is told in the courtroom that he only needs to pay 50 rupees to be freed of his charges. When he looks in despair at the judge to tell her that he can’t afford that price, he turns around to see all the men behind him pulling money out of their pockets to give to him. The reaction shot comes in when the camera cuts to a medium shot of Max with a big smile on his face, and a feeling of being satisfaction and happiness. This is a heartwarming scene because it shows the solidarity and strength of Hazari and his community.
Towards the end of the movie, there is an uplifting change in Hazari’s status, which is shown through the camera angle: the viewer sees him in low angle shots, giving him more strength and formidability in the scene. Where he once crouched in front of other people, he now stands tall and powerful. For example, at one point Hazari and his family look down onto one of the streets and see the people all looking up at him and waving and smiling. This specific position causes the viewer to look up to Hazari, promoting his status.
The wedding scene at the end of the movie seems almost like a dream in how idyllic it appears to the viewer – medium close-ups are almost completely blurred behind the character on screen, and there is a lot of blurred movement in the background of a lot of the medium shot scenes. This, in conjunction with the bright colors of the Indian wedding, creates a sense of joy and happiness.
Nonetheless, the film ends on a bittersweet note: Max and a wounded Hazari walk off into an empty street away from the wedding. Using a quick jump cut back to the wedding, and continuing to shift to an establishing shot of the outdoor post-wedding celebrations, the shock of Hazari’s wound is softened – but in the end, Max and Hazari are no where in sight.